Gotham Walls and Finishes

Great 4.8(24)
Great valueLicensed
  • 24 hires
  • Based in Staten Island, NY
  • 17 years in business
  • 3 employees
  • Responds in about 4 hours
  • Background checked
  • License verified

About Gotham Walls and Finishes

Our team of professionals serves NYC for over 20 years. We have perfected every step of the process from the comunication, protect the floors , dust containment, to the final result. Our cherished customers have paid us back with their own loyalty, giving us repeated business year after year. While we have extensive knowledge in most types of construction projects, we chose to focus on paint, water damage repair and drywall installation.

Reviews

Thumbtack customerOct 2026

Carmine and his brother were so lovely and honest. Carmine gave me full information about what he was doing and what needed to happen to fix a leak in my ceiling. He went above and beyond and fixed a windowsill issue at the same time. They painted and didn’t haggle for more money than the original quote. I’ll definitely hire him again for drywall and for painting and for advice.

Deena b.Mar 2025

Carmine was great! He was able to squeeze me in so I could make my deadline. He communicated well, came when he promised and finished the work as planned. He gave me a good introductory rate, was flexible on the project and took care of a few other small things while he was there. I will absolutely use Carmine again.

Elizabeth E.May 2021

Carmine was honest and upfront. He gave me a timeline and stuck to it. His work was quick and efficient. I would use him again for another project for sure.

Kim C.Apr 2021

Carmine did an excellent job I highly recommend and the price was right I was in aw at the finish work he did thank you. I will reach out to him again

Peter M.Nov 2018

Carmine came in the morning to start a chase molding project for me, after a consultation he help me to move forward with wainscotting idea. The result was great! Highly recommend him.

Sharon L.Oct 2018

Carmine redid my door, window frame, and window sill molding. I everything corrected from work done previously. The result was far better than I ever expected even though he had to do extra work because of the condition my over 100 year-old apt. walls. He has a great sense of design, very good with attention to detail, and is easy to work with. I plan on having my kitchen renovation with him soon. I am so happy to have found him. Attached is a photo of the beautiful job he did on my window sills. I think the sill moulding matches the window frame beautifully.

Eric S.Oct 2018

Carmine cape for a quote, was professional and trustworthy. I was happy to meet him. I didn’t end up withering with Carmine due to the job changing and not needing the work i originally needed. I would recommend reaching out to him to anyone.

Rob S.Oct 2018

Carmine and his crew are awesome to work with. I have used him on a few jobs at my employment and at my home. They can handle all types of jobs at a great price and in a quick timeframe. The best part is communication. He is easy to get in touch with and always responsive. I will keep them on as my contractor for years to come. Thanks!

Carlos D.Sep 2018

Carmine was very professional. He did an excellent job on my base and crown molding. I would definitely recommend Carmine. Just make sure to be clear regarding specifics, as with any other contractor. Overall good work and service

Allison W.Jul 2018

***updating my feedback after hiring for a second project*** I hired Carmine to build a closet along with his brother Vito to redo my bathroom. Huge mistake, see photos and decide for yourself what kind of work that they do Carmine/Closet: - took 2 months and never finished - did sloppy work, glueing pieces of wood together that he cut wrong, nails not going through pieces correctly etc - he has no carpentry skill, basic handyman jobs only. He could not make the closet doors himself, had to have someone else do it and then charged me for it - never came back to finish and I had to hire someone else to make built in racks and shelving - also never finished sanding or painting, had to hire someone else to do this as well Vito/Bathroom - cut tiles sloppy, grouted but never sealed it, so I had to regrout and seal the entire shower tile area over again - smeared black grout all over floor tiles then sealed it, had to take off sealant and regrout and reseal tiles myself - installed medicine cabinet without centering it over the vanity and then argued with me about fixing it - installed all of the faucets backwards, had to reinstall hot and cold water for faucets - this guy never measured anything and we ran into the same kinds of problems over and over again BUYER BEWARE

Steven P.Oct 2017

Carmine was great. Would hire again for sure!

Gabriel K.Feb 2017

Needed repair for water damage in a ceiling, re-calling a tub, and drywall repair in a bedroom. It was very easy to make and appointment for an estimate and started work the following day. He was very thorough, making sure there were no other leaks in the ceiling and did the job quickly and well. Based on my experience I would highly recommend him.

Services

Compare other pros

Gotham Walls and Finishes★ 4.8
Check availability